Thanksgiving means many things: gratitude, turkey, Carvel’s Tom the Turkey cake, football, and to my continued Canadian astonishment, marshmallows on sweet potatoes. But for millions, it also means dealing with houseguests. We’ve all had our share of unsavory ones. When I was in 8th grade, I hosted an exchange student from France whose bad behavior ranged from snootiness to destroying sports equipment and soliciting my stepsister in the middle of the night. More recently, every time a certain member of my wife’s family stays with us, multiple pairs of underwear are found in the bathroom trash. They’re not soiled; it turns out he never travels except to see us, is obsessed with the weight of his bag, and always packs his oldest underwear to discard before his return trip.
But my guests don’t hold a candle to historically bad guests. Lord Byron four-poster-bed-surfed from country estate to country estate and his schedule consisted of waking up at dusk, drinking all night, firing pistols indoors for target practice, and – French-exchange-student-like – attempting to seduce his host’s wife, sister, or brother. Then there’s Julian Assange who landed at London’s Ecuadorian embassy and stayed for seven years, riding a skateboard through the narrow hallway, eating with his hands and wiping his fingers on his clothes, refusing to shower or bathe, and failing to maintain a litter box for his cat. But the worst houseguest, hands down, was Hans Christian Andersen. When Andersen met Charles Dickens in London, Dickens made the mistake we all make – an offhand invitation to visit next time in town. Andersen took him up on it in the summer of 1857, descending just as Dickens’ marriage was unraveling.
It was no fairy tale when the famous Dane came to stay. While Andersen didn’t pull a Princess and the Pea by complaining about the bedding, on his first morning at Gad’s Hill he descended the stairs and announced he expected one of Dickens’ sons to shave him because it was the custom in Denmark for the son of the host to shave male houseguests every day. That summer Dickens was preparing to act in a friend’s play and Andersen attended a rehearsal, throwing Dickens and his fellow thespians for a loop by sobbing ostentatiously through the performance. Andersen was an emotional Tinderbox; when word of a bad review reached him, he’d hurl himself into Dickens’ flower bed and weep. Denmark’s Naughty Boy also moaned constantly that the house was too cold. At a dinner party, watching Dickens offer his arm to a lady, the world’s worst Traveling Companion rushed in and elbowed the lady aside so he could take Dickens’ arm. It turns out the Emperor had no Clothes: Hans Christian Andersen was a deadly combination of unpredictable, rude, and boring.
Although he was only supposed to stay a week or two, the Ugly Duckling of houseguests lasted five weeks and still didn’t turn into a swan. After he finally departed, Dickens did some of his best writing on a note pinned to the guestroom door: “Hans Andersen slept in this room for five weeks – which seemed to the family AGES!”
You don’t need a license to be a houseguest, but perhaps you should. And why not? For decades, states have been licensing almost everything in sight. The fraction of jobs requiring a license has grown from approximately 5% in the 1950s to 25- 30% of the workforce. More than 1,100 occupations have been determined by at least one state to warrant regulatory time and attention including bangers like landscapers, bartenders, preschool teachers, alarm installers, florists, phlebotomists, taxidermists, parking valets, physical therapy assistants, and magicians.
The rationale for licensing is clear: protect consumers and – for jobs with physical risk – workers themselves. To perform the job in question responsibly and safely, one must earn the designated credential, pass an exam, and sometimes perform unpaid work – otherwise, it’s against the law. But how many professions truly require government oversight? One gauge is that only about 30 are regulated in all 50 states (and one of those is cosmetology). Most of the 1,100 licensed occupations are only licensed in one state. And within a state, there’s rarely rhyme or reason to the time and cost involved. According to Brookings, in Michigan it takes 1,460 days of education and training to become an athletic trainer but only 26 to become an emergency medical technician (EMT).
For all licensed occupations, the effect is to restrict competition in the labor market. Economists estimate that licensure reduces the number of available workers by up to 30%. And when supply of available labor declines, wages rise by about 20%. While that’s good news for the lucky licensed, higher wages translate to higher prices for the resulting products and services, which is bad news for everyone else. (The wage premium for licensed professionals is also partially offset by higher prices for the license-adjacent services and products they consume.) Estimates of the inflationary impact of licensing vary but easily mount to hundreds of billions of additional expense borne by Americans having a tough time making ends meet.
Why is healthcare so expensive? One reason is that we have a system that allows providers to set absurd list prices then discount for insurers (and – if you’re a doctor-senator – send collections agencies after your patients). Another is there aren’t enough licensed doctors or nurses. Or licensed workers in the building trades, creating a shortage of affordable housing. Rinse and repeat for a thousand other licensed occupations.
America’s licensure-industrial complex also raises barriers to economic mobility. Last year WorkShift reported on the dichotomy between the easy-to-earn certified nursing assistant (CNA) credential and the lengthy, expensive, and unpaid path to nursing licensure – a chasm that “keeps hundreds of thousands of healthcare workers locked below a living wage, often for decades.” In addition, lots of licensed occupations limit small business entrepreneurship. The Institute for Justice estimates that lower-income licenses like cosmetology require an average of a year of education or experience, an exam, and $260 in fees.
While licensing is more of a mixed bag for older workers – millions of whom benefit from their protected status – for aspiring career launchers it’s the equivalent of Hans Christian Andersen landing for five weeks. Not only are young Americans suffering the slings of higher prices, but also the arrows of artificial limits on good jobs; as many as 3 million good ones aren’t available thanks to licensing. So dumb war and dumb tariffs aside, it’s no wonder young people just voted for change with Gen Z preferring Democrats by nearly 50 points. The Minneapolis Fed estimates that licensure reduces the economic value of the licensed occupation by about 12%, with 30% of the cost borne by consumers paying higher prices and 70% by young workers shut out of the field. So if we care about helping Gen Z afford the things they need, it should be a priority to tear down barriers to good jobs.
***
The Democrats won on an affordability agenda. But what’s their track record on occupational licensing in the states they control? The question’s particularly pertinent given that, following the election, 22 states representing 53% of Americans will be under full Democratic control and 75% of Americans will have a Democratic governor. But since blue states presumably value consumer and worker protection, (as well as doing the bidding of licensure-loving unions) while red states prioritize economic liberty and free movement of labor, one might assume that licensing reform is a nonstarter for Democrats.
One would be wrong. Archbridge Institute recently released its fourth annual State Occupational Licensing Index and the results are fascinating. Utilizing a methodology that not only measures licensure but also related barriers to work (e.g., no license required for Alabama acupuncturists, but you can’t put pins in patients in Prattville unless you’re already a physician), evaluating states on both licensure and other barriers across the 246 most commonly licensed occupations, then calculating an overall score, Archbridge ranks states from worst to best. Of the 10 states with the highest occupational licensing burden, five are deep red (TN, AR, AL, FL), three are bright blue (OR, NJ, MA), and the other two are the recently flipped Texas and North Carolina. Similarly, the 10 states with the lowest burden include five deep red states (MO, IN, WY, SD, MT), four blue states (NY, CO, AZ, PA), as well as Kansas.
Occupational licensing isn’t political. We might have suspected as much seeing how both Brookings and Cato have pressed for reform, as have Presidents Obama and Trump. It’s not political because how an occupation becomes licensed is a complex process of regulatory capture i.e., industries exerting political power to limit competition. As Morris Kleiner and Evgeny Vorotnikov wrote a decade ago:
In February 2016, three individuals went to the Minnesota House of Representatives to ask the state to create an occupational license to regulate the practice of music therapy. These were not people who had experienced or observed harms from the unlicensed practice of music therapy. They did not come bearing empirical evidence of a genuine threat to public health and safety from unlicensed music therapists. Instead, they were representatives from the music therapy industry, all privately certified music therapists themselves, arguing for licensure of their own occupation… Their primary argument was that licensing was necessary so that health care organizations could more easily differentiate between music therapists and “other non-music therapy musicians in health care”… Under the proposal, anyone wishing to work as a music therapist would need to earn a bachelor’s degree in music therapy, complete at least 1,200 hours of clinical training, pass an exam and fulfill an ongoing continuing education requirement.
Minnesota said yes, but the problem isn’t Minnesota; per the Index, it happens more often in Florida and Tennessee. So what kind of state allows business to co-opt government? To paraphrase President Obama, there are no red co-opted states or blue co-opted states; there’s the United Co-Opted States of America.
***
This is the landscape Democratic governors inherit, including new governors in Texas, Georgia, Iowa, Ohio, Nevada, and Alaska. And notably, Democrats didn’t only win on affordability, they also campaigned against corruption. Corruption doesn’t only come in the form of cryptocurrency or selling pardons or favors to companies, and certainly doesn’t start and end with fraud in Democratic-run cities and states. Corruption also creeps in when a justice-loving American can’t practice law without first spending three years at an expensive law school accredited by the legal industry trade association, or when a furniture-loving American is unable to set up shop as an interior designer thanks to state-level lobbying by the American Society of Interior Designers.
Some of the most impressive Democratic winners also campaigned on an abundance platform. So whatever the result of the permitting reform effort in the current lame duck session, newly empowered Abundance Democrats should push for occupational licensing reform next year. The bipartisan Build America caucus has proposed “incentivizing states to match licensing requirements to the actual risks of work.” It’s exactly the sort of thing that hundreds of newly elected Democrats in red and purple states can get behind. Fighting industry groups to reclaim pricing power as well as the ability to get a good job is the kind of populist economic initiative that wins elections.
Even without new federal incentives, state Democratic leaders can land a triple lutz – Affordability, Anti-corruption, and Abundance – by pursuing two related initiatives:
1. Zero-based Licensing
Zero-based budgeting allows organizations to reset their cost structures by starting from zero and adding only the resources they need to deliver their products and services effectively. There are no sacred cows in zero-based budgeting. Likewise, zero-based licensing starts from the premise that licensing is costly in terms of affordability and economic mobility. So the burden must fall on industry groups to justify the hassle. To maintain current licensing rules, they’ll need to show evidence that potential risks from unlicensed workers exceed the costs of licensing. And the evidence should be quantitative; a few horrific anecdotes aren’t enough. The impact would be a dramatic winnowing of licensed occupations, probably starting with Minnesota music therapy.
2. Narrower Credentials with Shorter Timelines
For remaining licensed professions – presumably concentrated in healthcare, the building trades, and aviation – states should mandate reform based on the example of welding where credentials are unbundled and stackable. It doesn’t take years for welders to start work and earn a living wage because certifications are specific to methods, metal, and thickness; aspiring welders can complete a short training program, become certified, and start working quickly. Keeping with the zero-based licensing concept, the burden should be on industry associations to prove the value of any combination of degree + unpaid work that keeps aspiring workers out of full-time employment for more than, say, a year. In healthcare, medicine/nursing/pharmacy will continue to pass with flying colors. Meanwhile the
Commission on Accreditation in Physical Therapy Education will fight an uphill battle to demonstrate that physical therapy assistants ought to be licensed, or that licensed physical therapy assistants – who aren’t allowed to touch patients unsupervised – need an associate’s degree with medical school-level coursework.
***
It’s too bad Hans Christian Andersen never wrote a fairy tale about occupational licensing. If he had, I imagine it’d involve a girl who’s so brilliant at braiding hair that her braids lie like golden ropes and stay in place for seasons at a time. That is, until she’s visited by an officious bureaucrat who boards up her shop until she completes a thousand hours of study at the Academy of Combs in addition to paying ten silver pieces for a braiding seal. And then a land where everyone is unkempt and unhappy – including the bureaucrat’s wife – because no one can afford braids. And the marriage unravels. And Dickens reads the story, upbraids Andersen, and Andersen throws another fit.
Of course, Andersen would have had it coming. As Benjamin Franklin put it, guests, like fish, begin to smell after three days – thank goodness Thanksgiving is a short holiday – let alone five weeks. But although states have allowed it to hobble American affordability and mobility through decades of Thanksgivings, our current approach to occupational licensing doesn’t even need three days to smell fishy.